A new study published in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition examines how different fats—specifically butter, margarine, and non-hydrogenated oils—affect heart disease and diabetes risk. The study found notable differences in the health outcomes linked to each type of fat.
For years, the debate over butter versus margarine has sparked concern about heart health, with experts generally agreeing that trans fats, commonly found in older margarines, should be avoided. Saturated fats, typically found in butter and dairy, have also been criticized for their potential link to heart disease. However, new research suggests that the health impacts of these fats may be more complex than previously thought.
The Role of Fats in Diet
Margarine, made from vegetable oils, was initially believed to be a healthier option for heart health compared to butter. However, many margarines contain trans fats, which are known to negatively impact health. Although the U.S. has taken steps to reduce trans fats in food, some countries still use partially hydrogenated oils. Non-hydrogenated oils like olive, safflower, and coconut oil are considered healthier options, but their impact on health is still being studied.
Researchers are continuing to investigate how long-term consumption of these fats affects heart disease and diabetes. Current guidelines suggest limiting saturated fats, but recent studies indicate that dairy fats may offer some benefits.
The Study: Methods and Findings
The study used data from the Framingham Offspring cohort, which followed over 5,000 participants for more than 40 years. After excluding individuals with certain characteristics, such as extreme body weights or excessive alcohol consumption, the study analyzed data from 2,459 participants. Researchers tracked participants’ diet through self-reported food diaries and then measured health indicators such as cholesterol levels and blood sugar after a follow-up period of four years.
Three main types of fats were analyzed: butter (both tub and stick forms), margarine (full-fat and lower-fat), and non-hydrogenated oils (such as olive oil and coconut oil). The goal was to determine whether these fats influenced cardiovascular disease (CVD) and type 2 diabetes risk.
Key Findings
The study found that higher consumption of margarine (7 grams or more per day) was linked to a significantly higher risk of heart disease (29%) and type 2 diabetes (41%) compared to those who consumed less margarine (2 grams or less per day). Interestingly, non-hydrogenated oils did not seem to affect diabetes risk, but they were associated with slightly higher body fat levels.
In contrast, those who consumed more butter (7 grams or more per day) had a 31% lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes. Both butter and non-hydrogenated oils were linked to a lower risk of cardiovascular disease, but the relationship was not straightforward and depended on the amount consumed.
When it came to cholesterol levels, butter was the only fat associated with higher levels of “good” HDL cholesterol and lower triglycerides, suggesting a potential heart health benefit. However, excessive consumption of non-hydrogenated oils (more than 7 grams per day) was linked to higher levels of “bad” LDL cholesterol.
Study Limitations
While the study provides valuable insights, it has limitations. Most participants were white and European, meaning the findings may not apply to all populations. The study also relied on self-reported dietary data, which can be prone to inaccuracies. Additionally, since the study is observational, it cannot establish cause-and-effect relationships.
Furthermore, at the time of the study, many margarines still contained industrial trans fats, which are now largely removed from modern formulations. This means that newer margarines may not pose the same risks as those studied here.
Practical Takeaways
For those trying to make healthier dietary choices, these findings offer important guidance. Moderate butter consumption might not be as harmful as once thought, and it may even have heart-health benefits, especially when balanced with other healthy dietary choices. However, it’s important to be mindful of portion sizes and overall saturated fat intake.
For people seeking to reduce their risk of heart disease and diabetes, using non-hydrogenated oils like olive or safflower oil may be a better option, as they offer a healthier fat profile.
Margarine consumers should opt for newer products that are free from trans fats to avoid the negative health effects associated with older margarines.
Conclusion
This study sheds light on the varying impacts of butter, margarine, and oils on heart disease and diabetes risk. While margarine—especially older versions with trans fats—can increase health risks, butter, when consumed in moderation, may offer benefits like improved HDL cholesterol levels. Non-hydrogenated oils are generally a good choice for heart health, but should be consumed in moderation. Ultimately, making informed, balanced dietary choices is key to supporting long-term health.
Related Topics
